RCALF: Colorado Lawmakers Reject Effort to End Deceptive Food Labels

Flickr / USDA


For Immediate Release: January 30, 2018

Corrected: Colorado Lawmakers Reject Effort to End Deceptive Food Labels

Denver, Colo. – On Monday the Colorado General Assembly’s House Committee on Agriculture, Livestock and Natural Resources heard testimony from dozens of Colorado cattle ranchers and Colorado consumers stating that multinational meatpackers and retailers were deceptively applying “Product of the USA” labels on foreign beef sold in Colorado grocery stores. Although this testimony was uncontested, and without any publicly disclosed committee debate, the committee voted 10 to 3 to prevent the only measure introduced in the Assembly to address these misleading labels from being debated on the Assembly’s floor by the states’ 65-member House of Representatives.

The bill, HB18-1043 introduced by Colorado Representative Kimmi Lewis (R), would have ended this consumer-targeted deception by reserving the “Product of the USA” label only for beef derived exclusively from animals born, raised, and harvested in the United States.

Testimony revealed that multinational meatpackers that distribute beef in Colorado were applying the USA label on beef from animals exclusively born and raised in one or more foreign countries and on foreign beef that was slaughtered in a foreign country and then subjected to only minor processing after entering the United States.

Lewis said about one-fifth of the beef available in the U.S. is imported but consumers do not know this because Colorado retailers are hiding the origins of imported beef.

Lewis told her colleagues, “All I’m asking is that you take this bill to the floor” because Colorado consumers have the right to know where their beef is produced. “Consumers are looking at “Product of USA” and it’s a scam,” she said.

Committee members who joined with Lewis to bring HB18-1043 to the floor for debate were Representatives Perry Buck (R) and Lori Saine (R).

Committee members who voted to defeat the measure without debate included Committee Chair Jeni James Arndt (D) and Representatives Jessie Danielson (D), Chris Hanson (D), Dominique Jackson (D), Donald Valdez (D), Daneya Esgar (D), Dylan Roberts (D), Hugh McKean (R), Jon Becker (R), and Marc Catlin (R).