NOBULL: Vilsack: Let WTO Resolve Country-of-Origin Labeling
Vilsack: Let WTO Resolve Country-of-Origin Labeling
Food Safety News
Nov. 15, 2013
The fate of mandatory country-of-origin labeling for meat products should be left out of the farm bill and handled by the World Trade Organization, said Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack at an event hosted by POLITICO on Thursday.
Country-of-origin labeling (COOL) laws require meat sold in grocery stores to indicate the original source country (or countries) on the label. Congress approved voluntary labels in 2002 and decided to make them mandatory in 2008.
But the U.S. meat industry largely opposes the rule, and Canada and Mexico – the two biggest sources of imported beef – have challenged the law within the WTO.
A group of Congress members have proposed repealing COOL as part of the farm bill, which Vilsack said would set a bad precedent. Lawmakers in the U.S. should allow the WTO to continue its investigation into the challenges against COOL, he said.
Opponents say that implementing a mandatory COOL law could invite international sanctions against trading meat with the U.S., as U.S. customers would possibly shy away from foreign-raised meat.
Proponents of COOL, such as the National Farmers Union and the Consumer Federation of America (CFA), are encouraging Congress to uphold COOL, saying it provides valuable information to American consumers. A May 2013 survey by CFA found that 90 percent of Americans believed they had a right to know the country of origin of meat they purchased.
Vilsack’s recommendation is totally lacking courage and integrity. It is also indicative of the perils of international trade agreements. The public wants country-of-origin-labeling and Congress was falling into line on this issue. As the fascists (a stark but technically-accurate noun as “facism” is literally defined as the merging of corporate and state power) sensed failure, they take the issue out of U.S. jurisdiction and into over-arching trade organizations. It’s a sad recommendation from an administration official and another sad day for the American people.
Tim, thanks for the post. When the USDA will shut down a relatively small packing plant in Peteluma CA like they did and not require enforcement of facts on a label because meat packers will be “harmed” for printing the truth, we have real problems in our political system. It is the concentration of wealth and power and the dirty money that buys political action.